Case File looks at one real business success or failure and what it shows about marketing. This one is a failure, and it's a classic: Tropicana's 2009 packaging redesign.
What changed
In January 2009, Tropicana launched a new look for Pure Premium, its best-selling orange juice. The image shoppers knew, an orange with a straw stuck in it, was replaced with a close-up glass of juice and a cleaner, plainer design. A large ad campaign, reported at about $35 million, was built around the new look.
The numbers
According to Information Resources Inc. data reported by Ad Age, between January 1 and February 22, 2009:
Unit sales of Tropicana Pure Premium fell 20%.
Dollar sales fell 19%.
That added up to roughly $33 million in lost sales.
The reversal
On February 23, 2009, less than two months after the launch, PepsiCo (Tropicana's parent company) announced it would bring back the original carton. Shoppers had complained that the new package looked generic.
Why it happened: distinctiveness
In R.E.D. Marketing, Greg Creed and Ken Muench (formerly of Yum! Brands) argue that leading brands are Relevant, Easy and Distinctive. The book doesn't cover Tropicana. Reading this case through that lens is my own take.
The orange with the straw was Tropicana's distinctive signal. In a crowded juice aisle, it was how people found their brand without reading a label. The new carton removed it, and with it went the fastest way to recognize the product. The juice inside hadn't changed. What changed was how easy it was to spot.
Why this matters for small brands
Small businesses redesign logos, labels and websites all the time, often because the owner is tired of the old look. Customers usually aren't. The parts of your brand people recognize at a glance, like a color, a shape or an image, are worth more than they look. If you change them, change them on purpose.
Planning a rebrand or new packaging and want a second set of eyes? Send me a note.
Sources
Ad Age report on IRI sales data, via Bloomberg Businessweek, April 2, 2009.
The Branding Journal, coverage of the 2009 Tropicana redesign (launch date and campaign budget).
PepsiCo announcement of February 23, 2009, as reported by EverythingPR and Ad Age.
Creed, G. & Muench, K. (2021). R.E.D. Marketing: The Three Ingredients of Leading Brands. HarperCollins Leadership.